Defense Outlines Flaws in LACC’s Final Report

first_imgKey documentary evidence heavily relied upon by the government to prosecute former National Port Authority (NPA) Managing Director Matilda Parker and her Comptroller Christiana Kparbar Paelay was discovered by the defense team yesterday to be laden with several inconsistencies.The document is considered by the LACC as the “Final Report in Allegations of Corruption at the NPA, regarding Wreck Removal and Port Security Consultancy.”It was collated from 15 persons including board members of the NPA and several entities.It was also based on that report that the defendants are being tried on multiple crimes, including economic sabotage.The pair has been on trial for allegedly awarding two contracts, removal of wrecks from Greenville Port and to provide security consultancy, to Denmar Enterprise owned by a Liberian businessman, identified as Deneah Martin Flomo in the amount of US$837,950.However, the LACC claimed the money was received without the work being done.A review of hundreds of pages of the documents in court yesterday revealed numerous examples of “voluntary statements” made by witnesses, including the defendants, who appeared before the LACC’s investigation, said to have contained inconsistencies.The final report presented to the court as state’s evidence was dated April 14, 2015, but showed that voluntary statements were collected from the witnesses between May and July of 2015, suggesting that the statements were taken between one to three months after the final report was compiled and submitted to the government.Another one was the exclusion of the voluntary statement made by the then NPA’s board chair, Mr. Nathaniel Barnes, when he was also investigated by the LACC.The only summary of Mr. Barnes’ voluntary statement reported in the LACC’s final report was left out.There were also two separate voluntary statements of the Managing Director of the Greenville Port, Mr. J. Darfur Wah, regarding the wreck removal at the port.In one of the statements, dated January 16, 2015, the LACC quoted Mr. Wah during its investigation as saying, “the wreck work was done on the port, but I don’t know, which company did the job, because I don’t have a copy of the contract.”Another statement dated July 13, 2015, after the LACC final’s report was submitted to government, also quoted Mr. Wah as saying, “I can remember the name of two companies that did the wreck removal. They are G-Four and the Buchanan Renewable Energy (BRE).”The defense team exposed these inconsistencies before the jury, which could likely influence their decision not to find the defendants guilty, when they cross-examined prosecution’s first witness and chief examiner of the LACC, Mr. Blamo Koffa.When Koffa was asked by Atty. Arthur Johnson, a member of the defense team, to explain about the dates appearing on the LACC’s final report, he said, “It is true as to what the document says, it happens because we conducted two separate investigations with the witnesses on those dates.”“We did the first investigation and submitted our findings to the Ministry of Justice (MOJ) on the April date.” He said, “Later the ministry asked us to do another investigation, which we did and subsequently submitted that report to the ministry on the other date.”According to Mr. Koffa, during his investigations of the witnesses, some of the witnesses did not cooperate with his team.However, when asked by Atty. Johnson how the investigation was conducted, he responded, “Everything went very well.”The case continues.Share this:Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)last_img read more

MOST READ

first_imgMOST READ LATEST STORIES Mayor Jonas Cortes said the amount would go to the reconstruction and relief operations of these towns and cities. Reporter Jucell Marie P. CuyosMORE STORIESnewsinfoFake cop accosts real cops, is arrested in PaterosnewsinfoAngara: Investigate DOH’s ‘constipated’ medicine distribution systemnewsinfoQuake disturbs Itbayat, Batanes anewMORE STORIESnewsinfoFake cop accosts real cops, is arrested in PaterosnewsinfoAngara: Investigate DOH’s ‘constipated’ medicine distribution systemnewsinfoQuake disturbs Itbayat, Batanes anew Fake cop accosts real cops, is arrested in Pateros View comments Tolentino: No more debate with Drilon on China deal BPI nets P13.74B in H1 Read Next Don’t miss out on the latest news and information. Fake cop accosts real cops, is arrested in Pateros Quake disturbs Itbayat, Batanes anew Abadia said half a million pesos will be allocated to the towns of Bantayan, Daanbantayan and Borbon while Bogo City gets the biggest share with P600,000. Daanbantayan and Bantayan in particular will each receive P550,000.The towns of Madridejos, Santa Fe, Medellin, San Remigio and San Francisco will each receive P400,000, while the towns of Pilar, Poro and Tudela in Camotes Islands, the towns of Tabogon and Sugod will receive P300,000.FEATURED STORIESNEWSINFOSenate to probe Tolentino’s ‘novel legal theories’ on oral agreementsNEWSINFOLocsin wants to drop ‘visas upon arrival’ privilegeNEWSINFOPalace open to make Dengvaxia usable again as dengue cases spikeThe cities of Tacloban and Ormoc and the towns of Albuera and Alang have been allotted P300,000 each.The amounts were determined based on reports of the extent of damage to property and total population of the area, Abadia said. Angara: Investigate DOH’s ‘constipated’ medicine distribution system PCSO to focus on improving transparency of gaming activities PLAY LIST 03:26PCSO to focus on improving transparency of gaming activities01:39Sotto open to discuss, listen to pros and cons of divorce bill06:02Senate to probe Tolentino’s ‘novel legal theories’ on oral agreements01:50Palace open to make Dengvaxia usable again as dengue cases spike01:49House seeks probe on ‘massive corruption’ in PCSO01:37PCSO estimates P250M in Lotto revenue loss due to suspension Senate to probe Tolentino’s ‘novel legal theories’ on oral agreements SMC bags Bulacan airport project THE Mandaue City government will allocate P6.9 million in cash assistance to 15 northern Cebu towns and fourtowns in Leyte that were hit by supertyphoon Yolanda.City Administrator James Abadia said P5.7 million will go northern Cebu while P1.2 million will go to the cities of Tacloban and Ormoc and the towns of Aleng and Albuera in Leyte province.ADVERTISEMENTlast_img read more